Skip to main content

The Law Office of Blerim Elmazi

Qualified Immunity in Texas: Can You Still Sue a Police Officer?

If you were injured by a police officer, one of the first things you will probably read about is qualified immunity. Many people come away believing it means police officers simply cannot be sued. That is not true.

Qualified immunity is a real obstacle, and it is especially demanding in Texas. But it has limits. Officers lose it when their conduct clearly crosses a line courts have already drawn, and it does not protect cities, counties, or private security at all. This guide explains how qualified immunity works, what makes Texas different, and what kinds of cases can still move forward.

The Short Answer

Yes, you can still sue a police officer in Texas. Qualified immunity can block a claim for money damages against an individual officer, but only if the officer’s conduct did not violate a clearly established constitutional right. When the facts are strong and prior cases have already condemned similar conduct, qualified immunity does not apply and the case can move forward.

What Is Qualified Immunity?

Qualified immunity is a legal doctrine created by the courts, not by Congress. It protects government officials, including police officers, from personal liability for money damages unless they violated a constitutional or statutory right that a reasonable official would have known about. The modern version comes from the U.S. Supreme Court’s 1982 decision in Harlow v. Fitzgerald. You can read a plain-language overview from Cornell Law School’s Legal Information Institute.

It most often comes up in civil rights lawsuits filed under 42 U.S.C. Section 1983, the federal law that allows people to sue state and local officials who violate their constitutional rights. Excessive force, false arrest, and unlawful search claims are all common examples.

How Courts Decide Whether Qualified Immunity Applies

Once an officer raises qualified immunity, the burden shifts to the injured person to show it does not apply. Courts use a two-part test, and they can choose which question to answer first.

Step 1: Did the Officer Violate a Constitutional Right?

In an excessive force case, the question is whether the force was objectively unreasonable under the Fourth Amendment. Courts look at factors such as how serious the suspected crime was, whether the person posed an immediate threat, and whether they were actively resisting or trying to flee.

In 2025, the Supreme Court made this step more favorable to victims in Barnes v. Felix, a case that came out of a Houston-area traffic stop. The Court unanimously rejected the Fifth Circuit’s “moment of threat” rule, which had limited courts to looking only at the split second when an officer used force. Courts must now consider the totality of the circumstances, including the events leading up to the use of force.

Step 2: Was the Right "Clearly Established"?

This is where most cases are won or lost. Even if the officer violated your rights, they keep qualified immunity unless existing case law made it clear that their specific conduct was unlawful. Courts do not accept general statements like “police cannot use excessive force.” They usually look for a prior case with closely similar facts that put the illegality “beyond debate.”

Why Qualified Immunity Is Especially Tough in Texas

Federal civil rights cases from Texas are appealed to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit, which is known for applying qualified immunity strictly. The court generally requires either binding Supreme Court or Fifth Circuit precedent, or a strong consensus from other courts, involving materially similar facts.

Recent decisions show how much the details matter:

  • Qualified immunity granted: In Smith v. Saenz (2025), the court held that no prior case clearly established that firing a pepperball round at a fleeing, non-compliant suspect was unconstitutional. A similar result followed in Sealey v. Mancias (2025), involving a non-deadly push of a fleeing suspect.
  • Qualified immunity denied: In Frosch v. Alsobrook (2025), the court refused to protect an officer who slammed a handcuffed, compliant, non-resisting person into a wall and the floor, causing serious injuries. Existing Fifth Circuit cases had already made clear that this kind of force is unconstitutional.

The lesson is that cases involving force against someone who was restrained, compliant, or not a threat have the best chance of getting past qualified immunity in Texas.

Who Qualified Immunity Does Not Protect

Qualified immunity is narrower than many people realize. It only protects individual government officials from personal liability for money damages.

Situation

Does Qualified Immunity Apply?

Individual police officers sued for damages

Yes, it can be raised as a defense

Cities and counties

No

Private security guards and bouncers

Generally no

Requests for court orders to change policies or practices

No

Criminal charges against the officer

No

 

If you were hurt by a bouncer or private security guard, different rules apply. Read more in our article on the average payout for an excessive force lawsuit against a bouncer.

Suing the City or County Instead

Cities and counties cannot claim qualified immunity. Under the Supreme Court’s decision in Monell v. Department of Social Services, a local government can be held liable when an official policy, a widespread custom, or a failure to train or supervise officers caused the violation.

These claims require evidence beyond the incident itself, such as prior complaints, internal policies, training records, or patterns of similar misconduct. They take more work to build, but they can be powerful because they hold the department accountable and are not subject to the “clearly established” test.

What About Texas State Law Claims?

Many people ask whether they can avoid qualified immunity by suing under Texas law instead. In practice, state law offers fewer options for police misconduct than federal law:

  • The Texas Tort Claims Act does not waive government immunity for intentional torts such as assault, battery, and false imprisonment.
  • The Act’s election of remedies provision can require courts to dismiss state law claims against an officer who was acting within the scope of their job.
  • Texas courts have not recognized a right to sue for money damages directly under the Texas Constitution.

For these reasons, most police misconduct cases in Texas are brought as federal civil rights claims under Section 1983, which is why understanding qualified immunity is so important.

What Makes a Case More Likely to Overcome Qualified Immunity?

No case is guaranteed, but the strongest police misconduct cases tend to share several features:

  • Video evidence from body cameras, dash cameras, cell phones, or nearby businesses
  • Compliance or restraint, such as the person being handcuffed, on the ground, or following commands
  • Little or no threat to the officer or others at the time force was used
  • Serious, documented injuries supported by medical records
  • Force that continued after the person stopped resisting
  • Prior cases with similar facts where courts found the conduct unconstitutional
  • Independent witnesses who saw what happened

An experienced civil rights attorney will evaluate these factors early, including researching whether prior case law clearly established that the officer’s conduct was unlawful.

What to Expect If an Officer Raises Qualified Immunity

Qualified immunity is usually raised early, either in a motion to dismiss or a motion for summary judgment. If the court denies it, the officer can appeal that decision right away, before trial. These appeals can add months or more to a case, so it is important to be prepared for a longer timeline.

You can learn more about each stage of the process in our guide on The Steps of a Civil Rights Lawsuit in Texas.

Timing also matters at the start. In Texas, the deadline to file a Section 1983 claim is generally two years from the date of the incident. Evidence like video footage can disappear much sooner, so it is best to speak with an attorney quickly.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can you sue a police officer for excessive force in Texas?

Yes. Excessive force claims are brought under the Fourth Amendment through Section 1983. The officer may raise qualified immunity, but it does not apply when prior case law clearly established that their conduct was unconstitutional.

Does qualified immunity apply to false arrest claims?

Yes. In false arrest cases, officers generally keep qualified immunity if a reasonable officer could have believed there was probable cause for the arrest, even if there was not. Arrests made with no reasonable basis can still lead to liability.

Does qualified immunity protect the police department?

No. Cities and counties cannot claim qualified immunity, although claims against them require proof that a policy, custom, or failure to train caused the violation.

What is the average payout for an excessive force case?

Payouts vary widely depending on the injuries, the evidence, and whether the case settles or goes to trial. For a detailed breakdown, see our guide on the average payout for an excessive force lawsuit against a police officer.

How long do I have to file?

Generally two years from the date of the incident for a Section 1983 claim in Texas. Some related claims may have shorter notice deadlines, so it is best to act quickly.

Talk to a Dallas Excessive Force Attorney

Blerim Elmazi lawyer in North Texas

Qualified immunity is a serious hurdle, but it is not the end of the road. Many strong cases move forward every year, especially when the evidence shows force used against someone who was compliant, restrained, or not a threat. At Elmazi Law, we help clients across Dallas/Fort Worth evaluate their cases honestly and pursue accountability when officers cross the line. Learn more on our Excessive Force page, or submit a case inquiry to speak with an attorney.

Disclaimer: This article is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Reading this article does not create an attorney-client relationship. Laws change and every case depends on its specific facts. If you have questions about your situation, please contact an attorney directly.